The way I always put it, I don't think the best film in a franchise and your favorite film in a franchise have to be the same thing. I think Raiders is the best of the films, but I just can't deny...Doom is my favorite. The film is just pure, unabashed fun. It's really a strangely bizarre film too.
It's both the darkest Indy film and the goofiest at the very same time. You have hearts being ripped out of sacrificial victims with black magic who are then dipped in lava, slave children and child violence, Indiana getting mind controlled and easily the most beaten up out of any film, people falling hundreds of feet to get eaten by crocodiles, Indy impaling someone on a kabob in the middle of a nightclub, a guy hung from a ceiling fan and crushed by a giant rock crusher, it goes on and on. I mean if you look close at the details, the Kali statue in the sacrificial chamber is covered in severed limbs, as is the warning statue in the jungle covered in severed fingers. Jeez! Yet you also have in essence everything with Willie Scott, Short-Round, the dinner scene, slapstick comedy, the jungle scene, on and on. But for me, the sheer wit of Harrison really made the comedy work. I think he's the master of banter and can heighten any co-stars performance just by proximity.
This film, I always argued, is a perfect "edgy" kids movie. I saw it when I was probably six years old and did not stop playing out the bridge and mine cart scene for weeks. I think a lot of people originally didn't like it for a number of reasons. For starters, it's just so extremely different from Raiders. I admire that they went a gutsy original route, but it's still an incredible serialized style adventure.
I think another aspect people didn't appreciate was...well...it's not a Christian relic or mythology, so a lot probably didn't know the mythologies. Now granted it is a sort of hodgepodge of cultures, but it does draw on real-life things. The Thuggee cult was real, they did plague the British colonials. It's actually where the term "thug" originates. However, they were more just street peddling thieves and crooks rather than some evil death cult. Usually they'd find a traveler, act as a sort of guide or friend, then murder them in their sleep. The Thuggee were a huge organization though and were branded menaces. One interesting punishment was sometimes, if caught, they'd be executed totally terrifyingly by having their head crushed by an elephant. Legit! The film seems to have incorporated a lot of Meso-American culture into the Thuggee, the sacrifices appear to be inspired by that of the Aztecs, the Prince uses a Haitian voodoo doll, Mola Ram even has a small shrunken head on his headpiece.
Then lastly, the artifact is fictional...but like a lot of the other aspects of the film, it has a basis in reality. The Sankara Stones are magical fictionalized versions of Shiva Lingam stones, appearing much like how Indy describes them in the film. They're river stones, very smooth and oval in shape. The local cultures believe they had abilities.
And can we talk Mola Ram? For a main villain that oddly doesn't get much screen time, my dude is awesome. My favorite Indy villains, by far, and def. the most intimidating IMO. I absolutely love his design. I always get chills when he says "You will, Dr. Jones. You will become...a true believer," with all that steam coming off his frighteningly grinning face.
The let's talk Willie Scott. I think she gets WAY too much guff. I don't think she's that bad at all, but I know she's been sort of deemed the Jar Jar of the franchise. I think that's so unfair. Sure she's annoying at times, but I enjoy her character for what it is. Plus I'm sorry, but Capshaw was a baaaabe in that.
Some of my other favorite moments?
"The Antidote..." "For what?!" "The poison you just drank, Dr. Jones!" Just the sheer suspense of that whole scene. The corks popping...the negotiation...the poison. It's so well-made. It feels so classic cinema.
"Nice try, Lao Che!" Classic Indy humor, out of the frying pan and into the fire. Indy is fascinating to me in that it's one of the only action adventure film series that really utilizes humor a lot, but I always found Indy humor to be my sense of humor.
"Fortune and glory, kid. Fortune and glory," with the shooting star. Still one of my favorite shots in all of the films.
The whole trek through the jungle montage is gorgeous. Yet another underrated aspect of the film is the score, I love the Short Round theme and Slave Children's Crusade. Outside of the main Indy theme, they're my favorite sub-themes in the franchise. Now I always wondered something. Indy tells Willie, "Giant vampire bats," but are they in the continuity of the film? Because in reality, they're clearly fruit bats. How I like to interpret the scene? He knows they're fruit bats, he simply said that to toy with her.
"You cheat, Dr. Jones, you cheat!" Short Round will forever be awesome and hysterical. I really wish they had just a throw-away line explaining whatever happened to him.
"Snake surprise!" "What's the surprise?" The dinner scene seems to be one people either love or hate, but as a fan of over-the-top and gross out horror, I found it hysterical.
The whole stubborn flirtation scene is so well-acted and I crack up ever time when Indy pushes the statues breasts and Willie goes "Hey, I'm RIGHT HERE!" with her hands over her chest. LMFAO!
"WE! ARE GOING! TO DIE!" and it's all expressed through hand gestures. Plus come on, the bug pit and spike trap are awesome.
The intro of Mola Ram still gives me goosebumps. "He's still alive..."
Short Round burning Indy to shake him out of the mind control is genuinely heartbreaking. "Indy...I love you."
The shot of the guard sliding through the gravel after being punched out and the pan up to the hero shot of Indiana in the doorway is just...wow. Then the score "Slave Children's Crusade" begins during the rescue and the fight with the giant Thuggee begins and 6 year old me was just like, "This is the best movie ever!" One thing that always fascinated me was that even Indy tries to save the guy, even he's like "No one deserves to go out like this!"
...and then the mine cart sequence happens and I'm even more on cloud 9.
...and the the bridge scene happens, it's now my favorite boyhood movie ever. "It's time to meet Kali...IN HELL!"
I love every frame of this film.