Good points, when I think of what could be turned into a playset for this line I keep hearing Mark Hamill's lines from the CC footage.
"Real sets, practical effects..."
I think that sums up a lot of TFA and it's locations.
Jakku didn't have near the iconic locations that Tatooine had. Sure you could have the AT-AT home...or you could just take your already existing AT-AT and tip it on it's side.
The outpost wasn't much to look at. Various tents and stands don't make for much of a playset (watch they release all of Jakku now).
Once they get off Jakku, the first new location does have playset value. Han's ship. I know how I'd make it, hallways that connect so you could build endless corridors. They wont make that. They wont feel like there's enough of an iconic look or classic scenes to recreate. The more I think about it, the more I agree.
Next they go to Maz's castle. This is one place I could see them doing something with. They have the Cantina quality going on inside. They could have a ruins look on the outside complete with exploding walls to knock Stormtroopers off their feet. It has potential but only if you build it up bigger than the small POTF2 playsets. I don't see them committing to anything big enough to do it justice. Cardboard interior set maybe...
A lot of the other locations are very "boring" in the movie. As noted above you can't exactly sell the woods, or a snowy terrain.
Starkiller base is the best hope, but how do you do it? Do you make it large like the vintage Death Star playset? What do you include. It didn't exactly have the same iconic scenes that ANH had regarding the Death Star. There was the swing across, the trash compactor, the detention block area. What are the scenes in TFA that you could include. The verbal confrontation on the catwalk? It's just not as recognizable.
The more I think about it, the more I'd settle for a cardboard Maz's and consider myself lucky.
TFA just went to so many different places yet none of them stood out in a way that Yoda's hut, or the Lar's homestead does.
"Real sets, practical effects..."
I think that sums up a lot of TFA and it's locations.
Jakku didn't have near the iconic locations that Tatooine had. Sure you could have the AT-AT home...or you could just take your already existing AT-AT and tip it on it's side.
The outpost wasn't much to look at. Various tents and stands don't make for much of a playset (watch they release all of Jakku now).
Once they get off Jakku, the first new location does have playset value. Han's ship. I know how I'd make it, hallways that connect so you could build endless corridors. They wont make that. They wont feel like there's enough of an iconic look or classic scenes to recreate. The more I think about it, the more I agree.
Next they go to Maz's castle. This is one place I could see them doing something with. They have the Cantina quality going on inside. They could have a ruins look on the outside complete with exploding walls to knock Stormtroopers off their feet. It has potential but only if you build it up bigger than the small POTF2 playsets. I don't see them committing to anything big enough to do it justice. Cardboard interior set maybe...
A lot of the other locations are very "boring" in the movie. As noted above you can't exactly sell the woods, or a snowy terrain.
Starkiller base is the best hope, but how do you do it? Do you make it large like the vintage Death Star playset? What do you include. It didn't exactly have the same iconic scenes that ANH had regarding the Death Star. There was the swing across, the trash compactor, the detention block area. What are the scenes in TFA that you could include. The verbal confrontation on the catwalk? It's just not as recognizable.
The more I think about it, the more I'd settle for a cardboard Maz's and consider myself lucky.
TFA just went to so many different places yet none of them stood out in a way that Yoda's hut, or the Lar's homestead does.