I don't know about that, I have actually purchased one of the Han troopers that originated from him and they are pretty spot on. This dude has a history of reproduction items (like handbags) that landed him in jail from what i've read online, so he definitely has connections for top-quality knock offs.Yeah, but it’s horrible. No one would be happy with it. And it certainly won’t ever actually fool anyone. Rest easy!
NOTE: The picture he uses in the auction looks great, but what he sends you I promise looks NOTHING like that.
The weapons have features that are not present in the vintage, they look rather different. For the figures, they are larger, have subtle molding differences and the COO information is printed on the back leg, not molded. For the card, there is the obvious printed wear and the 'RETRO' sticker. So, the sticker could be removed. Not sure it fool many, but it will certainly goof up my eBay searches!I was talking with a friend that is well known in the community. He's at celebration right now and was looking over the Retro line that was on display there. I asked him if there were evident tells on them that would let people know that they were obviously not originals. His response was that to most collectors it would be obvious that the weapons in particular are not originals. So that gives me some hope on them. I'm sure when the figures are released that there will be more conversation on the tells of how they differ.
Dont worry hopefully Hasbro puts all the Repro sellers out of business by redoing all their classic line. that will satisfy the people who just want to scratch the nostalgia itch and. I'm all for Hasbro/Kenner repro lolHm. Most examples of this kind of thing I’ve seen have been pretty shoddy; it’s a concern that these guys are getting good enough to fool even some of us. And you’re right—it’s a repro. I can understand some actual figure lovers wanting something that looks like the beautiful Yak for their own entertainment, and thus taking the cheap way out. But most people getting in on this probably have some deceptive purpose. It’s a shame.
I hate the repro figs he does but the 12 that were never done I can't pass on. They are cheaper than what they cost me in parts to make customs.
https://www.thefansstrikeback.com/revenge-of-the-toysI hate the repro figs he does but the 12 that were never done I can't pass on. They are cheaper than what they cost me in parts to make customs.
I don't have a problem with the figures because they are marked SMC ( Smith Lord Creations ) on the back of the leg. Also the Luke stormie has a different face mould. It gives collectors who aren't able to afford the originals a chance to own a figure that's very close to the original...although his figures aren't cheap at £40 :O
That's why I eventually had to cut up the staff from my SLC Yak Face, because I knew that eventually I would get it mixed up with one of my authentic Barada staves.I just wish his high quality repro weapons had markings on them! His stuff is so hard to tell from vintage now and it makes me sad.
Yeah, I feel the same way. I'm not an investor or a museum curator. I'm in this hobby for the fun of it and to recreate my childhood as much as possible. When it stops being fun is when I give it up.That's actually an issue I have with collecting some of the more expensive figures, even if I were to purchase them, they'd end up locked away, so as to not damage them...when you reach that point, I don't see the fun in it. I like to keep figures out on display at times, and I actually like to handle them as a loose collector. Having something sealed in an acrylic tomb does nothing for me.
Thanks, I've since replaced the POTF2 EV-9D9 with a vintage one, but the POTF2 figure was an acceptable stand in.BigBarada
Your Jabba's Henchman are ready to kick Butt!!!
Looks good! The EV 9D9 mixes in their well too! You need to have him torture a Gonk next!
Since when is taking options away from adult collectors, who should have the freedom to buy what they want without interference from internet busybodies, a victory?Looks like vintage collectors have had another small victory. A few months ago Smith Lord Creation had his Paypal account shutdown and now after complaints eBay have removed all their figures. The only place you can now buy them is the website fanstrikesback and I'm guessing it won't be long until their PayPal is also closed.
Reading through all the comments it seems the majority don't have a problem with their figures as they are clearly marked on the back of the leg. It seems most of the animosity is due to the weapon's. The fact that they are advertised as bouncing and floating like vintage making them indistinguishable from the originals is almost as if Fans Strike Back are giving the middle finger to the vintage collectors and asking for a battle. I'm sure if they marked their weapons as they do with their figures vintage collectors would back off a bit...and we could all get along
I remember back around 1994, when the Star Wars Micro Machines first started coming out, some guy was selling individual MM vehicles as authentic, vintage Kenner toys for authentic, vintage Kenner prices. This was back in the days when online sales listings often couldn't support image files. So, this guy sold the tiny Micro Machines A-Wing for $200, as if it was the 3.75" scale Kenner A-Wing. The only way anyone was able to find out that it was a scam was for someone to actually buy one of the toys and then report back that it was a Micro Machine, tiny enough to be shipped in an envelope, and there was no "buyer protection" from websites back then to give him any hope of getting his money back. So, should vintage collectors have lobbied to have Galoob cancel their Micro Machines line because a few collectors got scammed? There has always been some level of risk when buying secondhand toys from unscrupulous sellers.If vintage collectors are trying to put Fans Strike Back out of business they would view having their eBay shut down as a victory.
I don't think the concern is with collectors who buy the repro figures and weapon's and keep them in their private collection. The concern is with those that try and pass the figures and weapons off as vintage. There has already been a Smith Lord Yakface sold as vintage ( with a vintage price tag ) on echo base. I can only imagine how many Fans Strikes Back weapons have been bought and then sold as vintage by dishonest sellers.
For whatever reason Fans Strike Back won't mark their weapons and just to infuriated vintage collectors further they even boast on their website their weapons bounce and float like vintage, to vintage collectors its like a red rag to a bull.
Personally I think a lot of this could be avoided if they'd simply mark their weapons the same way they do their figure's. That way there would be no confusion and people could collect vintage or repro however they choose.
Lighten up mate. It's not 'theft' it helps out collectors like me who wouldn't pay hundreds of pounds for these figures but want one for a display (in my case a barge display). It's not hurting anyone except the pride of a few über collectors who get horny when they think about the 1978-85 air trapped inside their vintage bubbles.SmithLordCreations is theft. Unofficial and bootlegging. No question.
Buy what you want but the guy is not just breaking the law but also producing deceptive products.
Just read Adam Pawlus write an awesome piece of this over on Galactichunter.com as part of this weeks Q&A.
Whats that? Buy officially licensed action figures? What next, do I need a license to use my toaster?Lighten up mate. It's not 'theft' it helps out collectors like me who wouldn't pay hundreds of pounds for these figures but want one for a display (in my case a barge display). It's not hurting anyone except the pride of a few über collectors who get horny when they think about the 1978-85 air trapped inside their vintage bubbles.
As for Pawlus I often like what he says but he must have a different version of eBay from me if he thinks the original Blue snag is readily available.
SmithLord are providing a valuable service, they add to the fun of collecting for those of us who always wanted to just rip the toys off their cards. Everyone else needs to get off their high horse and remember that Star Wars doesn't belong to them.
Nonsense. He sells reproduction figures as reproduction figures and you get exactly what you pay for. There is no instance where the guys at Smith Lord Creations or TheFansStrikeBack are deceiving people about the items they are selling. The fact that unscrupulous secondary market sellers are passing these items off as legitimate has nothing to do with SLC or TheFansStrikeBack.SmithLordCreations is theft.
No because they're reselling their own product that was from an officially licensed vendor. Smith....is not legitimate. He is using someone elses names etc...Aunt Beru from the Addams Family.Nonsense. He sells reproduction figures as reproduction figures and you get exactly what you pay for. There is no instance where the guys at Smith Lord Creations or TheFansStrikeBack are deceiving people about the items they are selling. The fact that unscrupulous secondary market sellers are passing these items off as legitimate has nothing to do with SLC or TheFansStrikeBack.
If people were to resell figures from Hasbro's Retro Collection on eBay as authentic vintage figures, would you then accuse Hasbro of theft?
They are not officially licensed toys and I don't believe anyone buying from SLC is under the impression that they are. Again, no deception is taking place, thus no theft is taking place.Smith....is not legitimate. He is using someone elses names etc...
That's absolutely untrue. Intellectual property and trademark rights are a real thing. If you're making money off of a property that you don't have the legal rights to, it's theft. There's no way around that. Now, you might not care but that doesn't alter the legality of what he's doing. Would someone fill the market void that "Smith Lord" would leave if he were to stop producing repros? Undoubtedly. But again, that has no bearing on the legality of what he is doing.... thus no theft is taking place.
No. Hasbro has the legal rights to a Star Wars license. "Smith Lord" does not. Don't confuse your support of what "Smith Lord" does with the legality of what he does. Those are two separate things.If people were to resell figures from Hasbro's Retro Collection on eBay as authentic vintage figures, would you then accuse Hasbro of theft?