Editing of the PT

[Cornfedbigdaddy]

This is an offshoot of the Screenplay VS Plot discussion we've had. I realize many of us were disappointed with the PT final product. Do you think if the 3 movies were reedited for clarity and pacing and throw in a maybe a few reshoots there would be a significant improvement? I do realize that the acting and some of the dialogue leave much to be desired so I'm not implying the movie would be vastly improved but with a few cuts here and there and maybe an addition or two, could the final product be improved?

 

[General_Solo76]

I think I'm one of the few people on these forums that like them just the way they are, so I'd say just no, just let them be.

 

[Z95_Headhunter]

I am not a prequel basher, but I would criticize the music editing of the prequels, particularly Episode II. It's just super sloppy, especially in the Geonosis arena battle section. Lots of abrupt changes.

 

[Julythrunov]

This is an offshoot of the Screenplay VS Plot discussion we've had. I realize many of us were disappointed with the PT final product. Do you think if the 3 movies were reedited for clarity and pacing and throw in a maybe a few reshoots there would be a significant improvement? I do realize that the acting and some of the dialogue leave much to be desired so I'm not implying the movie would be vastly improved but with a few cuts here and there and maybe an addition or two, could the final product be improved?

I think it would improve some things. By how much? Who knows