Best collecting finds

Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
1,068
Reaction score
436
What are your best, most miraculous finds while adding to your collection? I'm not talking just Star Wars, but any collection. I thought of this because a friend of mine texted me last night and told me about an estate sale he went to last weekend. He didn't find anything worthwhile and was about to leave when he told the lady running it that he was hoping to find some books. She told him a book dealer had wiped them out the day before. She said all they had left was the dog book. When she brought it out, it turned out to be a first edition of Cujo. She said that since the dealer gave them more than they were hoping to get for the books, she let him have it for $5. He was ecstatic.

We got talking about great finds and I told him about two misses and one hit on my account. The first miss was in the late 90s when I was collecting POTF2 like crazy. My one collecting buddy called me and told me to meet him at the McDonald's we'd meet at way across town when we'd hunt over there. He had connections at a bunch of the stores and this guy at the Kaybee in an out of the way strip mall called him to say they'd found a box of old figures in the back room. He asked me to come along in case there was anything worthwhile left over after he got first dibs. As we drove over, he was excited because he was certain it was an old case of Shadow of the Empire figures. He'd somehow missed out on them when they were released. Instead, it was an old case of POTF figures. There were only half a dozen figures in the box, and nothing really rare, but we about flipped. They weren't worth as much then as now, but it was an awesome find. I forget if he posted about it in any of the forums at the time or not. Naturally, he bought them all so I missed out, but it was fun being there for it.

A few years later, I was mostly done collecting new figures, but I was searching for old figures from other lines. There was a toy shop nearby a friend of mine told me about. It was south of town and kept odd hours, but he said they had some really cool stuff. I went in and couldn't believe what a mess it was. Stuff was stacked from floor to ceiling and things weren't very well organized. I think there were a dozen different Star Wars "sections" in the store, a couple of which were just buckets of loose figures. In one of the sections marked "other toy lines," there were a bunch of figures in individual Ziplok bags. Some had cards, most didn't, and most were pretty beat up. It was all movie and TV action figure lines from the late 70s and early 80s. Nothing caught my eye until I saw a drab figure in a smaller bag with a $20 price tag. It was a Humanoid from the Mego Black Hole line. I nearly hyperventilated. I think they go for a couple thousand now. Back then, I think it was still a $200-300 figure. I took it to the register. The guy stared at it for a minute and a look of panic flashed over him. He was quiet for a second, then gave me a dirty look and said, "You don't think I'm that stupid, do you?" Before I realized what he was doing, he snatched it out of my hand then accused me of switching the price tag on it. I started arguing with him. He stuffed the figure into the cash register, closed it, then told me I had to leave. I argued a little more then gave up. He went out of business a few months later.

The time I made out like a bandit, I was at this little comic book store in the early 90s. The old guy who ran it was a bit of a curmudgeon and was ready to retire. At one point, he'd been the second-biggest shop in town, but he hadn't kept up with the times. His prices for back issues sometimes tended to be arbitrary and based more on his personal taste than the Overstreet guide. You could find some good deals, but you could also find really common books priced at 5-10 times what they were at other stores. Every shop in town had dime or quarter boxes. He had a dollar box. I was flipping through it and it was mostly garbage--low grade Richie Rich and Hot Stuff, things like that. Towards the back, I found a Hulk 181. I looked around and thought someone was playing a joke on me. I looked at it for a few minutes not really knowing what to do. I finally grabbed it and a few of the old Harvey comics and headed toward the register. I honestly thought I was going to pass out. When I got to the register, he flipped through the books. He pulled out the Hulk, looked it over, said, "Good book," then sold it to me for $1. I had to pull over on the way home to catch my breath, then flip through it to make sure it was the real thing. That's likely the best find I've ever had.
 
My greatest deal I got was when Walmart had the BMF on clearance and this particular store had a 50% off all clearance items. I forget the exact price, but it was around $30-$40. Still so happy I was able to get such a deal all these years later. 😁
 
Probably the last Kenner thing I got in the 80s was the Jabba's Dungeon set. The PotF version with Amnaman, Barada & EV-9D9. For $3 at the local KayBee. I didn't even realize it was how valuable it was until years later. I also got 2 blue Snaggletooth figures at a local music store for $6 each from their shelf of random SW stuff in the 90s.

For modern it would be the original UCS LEGO TIE Interceptor and X-Wing that I got from Target when they were on clearance for 75% off. And I didn't realize until I got home that the cashier had scanned the TIE twice instead of each one, so I got an even better deal than it normally would have been. $37.50 each plus tax.
 
Probably the last Kenner thing I got in the 80s was the Jabba's Dungeon set. The PotF version with Amnaman, Barada & EV-9D9. For $3 at the local KayBee. I didn't even realize it was how valuable it was until years later. I also got 2 blue Snaggletooth figures at a local music store for $6 each from their shelf of random SW stuff in the 90s.
I usually don't advertise the fact that I have two blue Snaggletooths. I have my original and one I got loose in the early 00s. It was from a comic book/toy store, no less, and was extremely cheap. They should have known better. The first time I told another collector about it, it turned into a shouting match because he didn't think anyone deserved to have two, and he wanted me to give him my extra.

I had quite a few missed opportunities on eBay in the late 90s and early 00s. It always came down to my wife saying stuff like, "You don't need to spend $75 on an Old B.O.B. figure! $100 is way too much to spend on a Turkish bootleg!" Things along those lines.
 
I just mentioned in another thread that there's a book that regularly goes north of 700 dollars. It's been out of print for about 30 years and nobody wants to give up their copy and there isn't even a pirated PDF version I can find. Good luck getting it from a library via Interlibrary Loan. Anyway, the other day I found a good copy for 250 on a used book website. Good binding, clean pages, dust jacket is intact, and all for 250 dollars. I snatched it up and I can easily flip it for what I paid for it and then some, but there isn't a chance I'm selling it.

Sometimes you're just in the right place at the right time.
 
I had grown out of toys by 1986 and missed the whole POTF wave.

I got back into collecting Star Wars in 1997. I wish I had kept my eyes open for vintage figures at that time. I was totally enamored with POTF2 instead.

I recall visiting a different state for a funeral in the early 2000s. I stopped by a KayBee and found the Ephant Mon wave on sale for $2.99. I had never seen him in the wild and the Ebay prices were too ridiculous for me to justify.

I bought the three remaining Ephants, kept two (one carded, one loose) and sold the third for $50+, as I don't recall the price exactly. I just remember it paying for all the other figures i purchased in that wave that day.
 
I just mentioned in another thread that there's a book that regularly goes north of 700 dollars. It's been out of print for about 30 years and nobody wants to give up their copy and there isn't even a pirated PDF version I can find. Good luck getting it from a library via Interlibrary Loan. Anyway, the other day I found a good copy for 250 on a used book website. Good binding, clean pages, dust jacket is intact, and all for 250 dollars. I snatched it up and I can easily flip it for what I paid for it and then some, but there isn't a chance I'm selling it.

Sometimes you're just in the right place at the right time.
My wife threw a fit a couple years ago when I spent $50 on a record. I explained to her that it's a $300 record and I was extremely lucky to find it so cheap. She told me nobody in their right mind would spend $50 on a record. I told her that nobody in their right mind would spend $300 on a $50 record, but any sensible collector would spent $50 on a $300 record. She said no record is worth that, and mentioned how the new records at Walmart are $20-30. I told her that lots of records are worth that. I pointed out that she had no issue with me buying hundreds of $3 figures when I was collecting Star Wars figures. I said that if I buy a $50-100 record, it's because that's what it cost. It also takes up less space than 30 figures, and everyone can enjoy it. She wasn't convinced. I figured that was a sign to not mention the $500 record. :D
 
I remember back in the mid to late '00s collecting McFarlane NHL figures. Once in a while I'd come across a chase at a place you wouldn't expect, like a small town drug store or grocery store that had little toy sections. Those were always exciting finds.

I came across a very rare Micro Galaxy Squadron ship at a liquidation store about a year ago. Prices have calmed a bit for it but at the time it was selling for a stupid amount on the secondary market, and I paid about $15.
 
I usually don't advertise the fact that I have two blue Snaggletooths. I have my original and one I got loose in the early 00s. It was from a comic book/toy store, no less, and was extremely cheap. They should have known better. The first time I told another collector about it, it turned into a shouting match because he didn't think anyone deserved to have two, and he wanted me to give him my extra.

I had quite a few missed opportunities on eBay in the late 90s and early 00s. It always came down to my wife saying stuff like, "You don't need to spend $75 on an Old B.O.B. figure! $100 is way too much to spend on a Turkish bootleg!" Things along those lines.
I actually traded one to one of my best friends for an extra Luke Stormtrooper he had.
 
I bought a beater-box Ion Cannon off eBay to test out the dimensions of my display space. I picked one because it had the variant version of Leia. When it arrived I realized I had stumbled upon the Kenner sign-off sample of the Ion Cannon. I asked the seller if they had any other SW stuff and they sold me the Trash Compactor sign-off sample. Seller had no idea what they were.
 
I once bought a big mixed lot of 90’s Star Wars toys because it had an (obviously fake, judging by the color) 1982 Kenner Micro Collection 4-Up stormtrooper hardcopy in it. But when I it in hand it had a single, very fine, mold line, indicating it came from a real Kenner mold. Not from a hobbyist mold
made off a borrowed hardcopy. I asked around and sure enough, a well known collector used the original mold to make it. Back in the 90’s when people still did crazy stuff like that.
 
mid-1980s drum machine at online estate sale. was bundled with same era audio mixer, both MIJ. sold the mixer so net purchase price was around 1/4 its value. will keep this one forever.
 
Not an action figure, but I remember back in the late '00s when I was still collecting hockey cards, and I bought a lot on eBay. The entire lot was all of one player and one of the cards was a 1 of 1. I still have it somewhere, safely secured in an acrylic case.
 
One that really impressed me was when a friend of mine was at an estate sale several years ago. He's into baseball cards and there was a small box full of 30-40 really old cards. He took a quick peak, asked the lady how much she wanted, and when she said $50, he said, "Sold!". The guy next to him offered $100. He argued that the lady had already agreed to $50. They bantered a bit, he offered $150, and she agreed saying it wasn't an auction. The first card in the box was in awful shape and missing one corner, not quite 1/4 of the card. I forget the player, but it was from the same series as the really expensive Honus Wagner card. In the shape it's in, he said it's worth around $250-300, but for him the bragging rights are worth a lot more. The others weren't nearly as impressive, but he said the entire lot (minus the first one) would have cost him upwards of $500 at a shop or on eBay.
 
Pretty much all of my best finds have been in auction lots or buying a box of stuff from a garage sale.

One specific purchase was at a garage sale where the person had a collection of old hardcover Isaac Asimov books, which aren't particularly valuable unless they are first editions... which none of these were... (I checked :confused:). BUT I happened to know that Ray Bradbury was rather resistant to reprinting his books, and being a sci fi person the one book in this collection that stood out didn't even have a name on the dust jacket. I wouldn't have known it was Ray Bradbury had I not opened it up to see which Isaac Asimov book it was. Not knowing much about the book, I bought it for $.50. I couldn't find any information even online after purchasing, which seemed odd. Eventually I learned my hunch was correct. It was "Dark Carnival", a rare collection of early magazine stories, which notoriously was a very small print. I eventually sold it for a couple hundred dollars.

I've gotten carded Star Trek movie, Battlestar, and Black Hole figures in a lot where I was buying simply for the loose pile of old action figures that managed to have a couple boxes come with that had figures on cards. I believe I got that lot for around $30.

I got about 8 loose cassette Transformers in a lot that I purchased because it had loose Star Wars vehicles for like $50.

I will say finds like that have been a lot less in the last 10 years now that everyone has a cell phone in hand and e-bay access all day long.
 
I will say finds like that have been a lot less in the last 10 years now that everyone has a cell phone in hand and e-bay access all day long.
I hate dealers with cell phones. We have a Goodwill processing center nearby where they get in tons of donations, sort them, then send them to stores. They put everything out on the floor first and people can pick through them. I guess it cuts down on the amount of work they have to do. Every day when they open, there's a bunch of eBay dealers there. They'll push and shove you out of the way (even if you're a 5-year-old kid) to get at the books, records, toys, etc. that they want to look through to resale. They'll attack a section, usually with a helper who blocks of a section. They'll start sorting through stuff, keeping what they want, and literally tossing the rest. Several of them intentionally damage items--ripping covers off books or throwing records on the floor. One guy told me they do that with the things that aren't valuable enough for them to waste time reselling, but that they don't other people to get for the rock-bottom prices at the center. It's been several years since I've gone because it's so ridiculous there. The last time I went, I managed to stop a dealer from damaging a book I wanted--it was part of a complete set of a kid's encyclopedia I had when I was little (only worth something to someone who had it as a kid, I guess). I also managed to find a record I wanted in a dealer's unwanted pile. He was one of the ones who wasn't damaging stuff intentionally. It wasn't terribly valuable--$25-30 on Discogs--but I'm guessing he made a mistake while looking it up because he was taking everything that was worth more than $3-4. I had my kids with me and a couple of the dealers got into huge shouting match as we were leaving. I decided it wasn't worth going back.
 
I hate dealers with cell phones. We have a Goodwill processing center nearby where they get in tons of donations, sort them, then send them to stores. They put everything out on the floor first and people can pick through them. I guess it cuts down on the amount of work they have to do. Every day when they open, there's a bunch of eBay dealers there. They'll push and shove you out of the way (even if you're a 5-year-old kid) to get at the books, records, toys, etc. that they want to look through to resale. They'll attack a section, usually with a helper who blocks of a section. They'll start sorting through stuff, keeping what they want, and literally tossing the rest. Several of them intentionally damage items--ripping covers off books or throwing records on the floor. One guy told me they do that with the things that aren't valuable enough for them to waste time reselling, but that they don't other people to get for the rock-bottom prices at the center. It's been several years since I've gone because it's so ridiculous there. The last time I went, I managed to stop a dealer from damaging a book I wanted--it was part of a complete set of a kid's encyclopedia I had when I was little (only worth something to someone who had it as a kid, I guess). I also managed to find a record I wanted in a dealer's unwanted pile. He was one of the ones who wasn't damaging stuff intentionally. It wasn't terribly valuable--$25-30 on Discogs--but I'm guessing he made a mistake while looking it up because he was taking everything that was worth more than $3-4. I had my kids with me and a couple of the dealers got into huge shouting match as we were leaving. I decided it wasn't worth going back.
They are scummy people who are financially desperate. I kinda don’t like buying anything from dealers anymore because I don’t know if they’re one of the “bad ones”.
 
I guess if it’s ANY collection then I have some others.

Went out to yard/estate sales around 2013. Got a cast iron cauldron for $5 to use at reenactments. Then as we were driving home, someone was putting Heroquest (with Kellar’s Keep) and Battlemasters out to the curb for free.

Then there’s my fossil collecting finds. The kids found a big rock with a fossil plant in it. They wanted me to break it and see what else was in it. I really didn’t want to because I thought we’d damage the plant. But it was pretty thick compared to its overall dimensions so I carefully attempted to split it open lengthwise. When I did, I was greeted with the sight of a 3” dinosaur footprint that hasn’t seen the light of day in about 202 million years. Give or take.
 
I guess if it’s ANY collection then I have some others.

Went out to yard/estate sales around 2013. Got a cast iron cauldron for $5 to use at reenactments. Then as we were driving home, someone was putting Heroquest (with Kellar’s Keep) and Battlemasters out to the curb for free.

Then there’s my fossil collecting finds. The kids found a big rock with a fossil plant in it. They wanted me to break it and see what else was in it. I really didn’t want to because I thought we’d damage the plant. But it was pretty thick compared to its overall dimensions so I carefully attempted to split it open lengthwise. When I did, I was greeted with the sight of a 3” dinosaur footprint that hasn’t seen the light of day in about 202 million years. Give or take.
All I ever found were broken bits of trilobites. :(
 
Back
Top