Results 1 to 7 of 7

Thread: Why wouldn't Luke kill the Wampa and stay in its lair?

  1. #1

    Why wouldn't Luke kill the Wampa and stay in its lair?

    I realize that Mark Hamill didn't even want to maim the Wampa as he is an animal rights activist, but surely Luke Skywalker the character should have realized that it would only take a couple more blows to the Wampa to kill it dead. Then he could just stay inside the Wampa's lair which would surely be a better shelter than being out in a storm on Hoth. I think he exercised poor judgement here.

  2. #2

    Why wouldn't Luke kill the Wampa and stay in its lair?

    Iím guessing he just woke up and was scared *****less. Itís not like he had mastered his fear yet with what little-to-no training he had. IIRC expanded universe material suggested the Wampa lair contained more of them too.

    Mark Hamillís animal rights love is irrelevant to Luke Skywalkerís actions. I canít help thinking what grilled arm of Wampa must taste like with a few beers and BBQ sauce however.




    Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
    Last edited by toadmeister; 05-27-2019 at 02:06 PM.

  3. #3
    Who says that liar is home to only the one Wampa? If he stayed there, he could be ambushed by more of them at any moment. The deleted scenes featuring Wampa showed them attacking in number. Luke probably was aware of what the type of creature was once he saw it, and would surely consider the existence of others. One could even speculate that he sensed unseen others through the Force. The way the cut of the movie stands, only the audience sees just one. So we're left unaware that they're actually numerous and persistent in the area of the Rebel Base.

  4. #4
    A lightsaber might be a formidable weapon, but Luke's not particularily skilled at using one at that point. The wampa is a fierce and giant predator. Would you rather cripple a rabid polar bear with your machete and get the Frak out of there? Or stay and risk more injuries by finishing it off. It lost one arm but could still maim easily if he stuck around.
    UPDATED! Check out my handy worksheet, listing every 1/18th release from 1978 till now
    Easily filtered on source, line, type, product, character name, species and category. Updated till 10-7-2018
    http://www.filedropper.com/rushiesrebelscumfile

  5. #5
    Quote Originally Posted by TheJuicyJawa View Post
    Who says that liar is home to only the one Wampa? If he stayed there, he could be ambushed by more of them at any moment. The deleted scenes featuring Wampa showed them attacking in number. Luke probably was aware of what the type of creature was once he saw it, and would surely consider the existence of others. One could even speculate that he sensed unseen others through the Force. The way the cut of the movie stands, only the audience sees just one. So we're left unaware that they're actually numerous and persistent in the area of the Rebel Base.
    pretty much what iwas going to say. i have always thought that there was a massive tunnel system in the caves and that there could have been a lot more wampas down there,
    possibly even more that were out hunting already could come home and be like "get offa my lawn boi "
    lando's not a man he's a power blaster

  6. #6
    The original script had several Wampas that they trapped in the rebel base. (C3PO pulls the sign off that says don't open door.) & several Imperial Snow Troopers are killed by said Wampas. This is the source of the "Is there paper in the future?" jokes

    Ultimatly the Wampas looked unrealistic & were cut from the story. You can see the cut scenes on youtube.
    This post was written is the sarcasm font. It looks like a regular font but contains sarcasm.
    Feedback BST
    I love this Bar! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fU3_zzZQzx0

  7. #7
    Quote Originally Posted by VideoViper View Post
    The original script had several Wampas that they trapped in the rebel base. (C3PO pulls the sign off that says don't open door.) & several Imperial Snow Troopers are killed by said Wampas. This is the source of the "Is there paper in the future?" jokes

    Ultimatly the Wampas looked unrealistic & were cut from the story. You can see the cut scenes on youtube.
    I'm so glad the whole Wampa attack subplot didn't make it into the final cut of the film. I feel like the Wampa was much more effective as a big scary creature you barely see, although I suppose one could argue that it seems like one of those unrelated-to-the-plot openings on The Simpsons in how it plays out in the final cut. Actually, I think there are some fragments of the Wampa attack remaining but they're barely noticeable. Isn't 21B working on a Tauntaun injured from the Wampa attack on Echo Base in the background of one scene?

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •